In Episode 425: Underwater Panther In Lake Erie, we are joined by Michelle as she recalls a time when she saw what appeared to be an underwater panther in Lake Erie. When the creature emerged from the water, the details she saw seemed almost prehistoric. Michelle later came across a picture on the internet of an ancient rock painting that strongly reminded her of what she had seen. On top of her strange panther sighting, she shares her other paranormal experiences, including an "old lady ghost" that seemed to take to Michelle's children in a motherly way.